- Macro Notes
- Posts
- Stocks Are At Records, but Consumers Are In A Recession Mood
Stocks Are At Records, but Consumers Are In A Recession Mood
Stocks are hitting records while sentiment hits a 70-year low. That gap is the whole story.
The stock market is acting like the good times are already here. Consumers are acting like they missed the invitation. The University of Michigan consumer sentiment index just fell to the lowest level in its 70-plus years of data, yet the S&P 500 has stacked eight straight weekly gains and the Dow just hit another record close. That is not normal. Usually strong markets and happy consumers move together.
IPO Watch (Sponsored)
Bloomberg is calling Elon Musk's upcoming SpaceX IPO "the biggest listing of ALL TIME."
But here's the thing - most investors will be locked out until AFTER it goes public.
Not you.
I've found a 'backdoor' that lets everyday Americans grab a pre-IPO stake in SpaceX right now.
Click Here for the FREE "SpaceX" Ticker
This Is A Historic Disconnect
The market is not just strong. It is expensive.
The S&P 500’s cyclically adjusted price-to-earnings ratio is around 40.8, using the Shiller CAPE measure. That has only happened one other time in the last 145 years of data: around the dot-com bubble peak.
That alone should get investors’ attention.
Now layer on the consumer side. Sentiment is not merely soft. It is at the lowest level ever recorded by the University of Michigan survey, even 10% below the prior low from June 2022, when inflation was raging at multi-decade highs.
That creates a strange market picture.
Stocks are behaving like growth, earnings, and AI productivity are about to carry everything higher. Consumers are behaving like inflation, gas prices, labor uncertainty, and war risk are already eating into daily life.
This is the core tension of the moment.
If stocks are right, the economy is looking through a temporary inflation shock and pricing a productivity boom. If consumers are right, the market is ignoring real pressure on household finances and paying too much for future profits.
Both can be partly true for a while. That is what makes this setup tricky.
AI Is The Bridge Between Euphoria And Anxiety
The market’s optimism is not random. It has a clear driver: AI.
Investors see AI as a profit engine. Companies can use it to automate tasks, reduce labor needs, increase output, and defend margins. That is bullish for earnings if revenue holds up.
Consumers see a different side. AI also means job displacement, fewer white-collar opportunities, pressure on middle managers, and a labor market where some roles are simply not coming back.
That is why the same theme can push stocks higher and sentiment lower.
A company that cuts headcount, automates workflows, and expands margins looks stronger to shareholders. But for workers, that same process feels like insecurity. The market sees efficiency. Households feel risk.
That is the uncomfortable truth behind this rally.
The AI trade does not need consumers to feel good right away. It needs companies to prove they can turn automation into earnings. That is why tech can keep leading even while sentiment looks awful.
But there is a limit. If consumers get squeezed too hard, demand eventually weakens. Productivity gains help margins, but they cannot fully offset a broad pullback in spending.
One of the most powerful economic warning signals has preceded every U.S. recession in the past 50+ years — yet most investors ignore it until it's too late. What is an "inverted yield curve"? |
Emerging Tech (Sponsored)
Tesla may be preparing for a major product shift at its Fremont factory.
Elon Musk has hinted at a new production-ready device that some are comparing to an “iPhone moment” for Tesla.
But the bigger opportunity may not be Tesla itself — it could be the small companies positioned around the supply chain before the next reveal hits.
This Is Not 2000, But It Rhymes
The comparison to 1999 and 2000 is not perfect, but it is useful.
Back then, stock valuations were extreme, but consumer sentiment was also high. The economy was growing, jobs were strong, inflation was cool, the U.S. government was running a surplus, and the internet was viewed as a mostly positive force.
Today looks very different.
The market has the tech excitement. It does not have the same consumer confidence.
AI is transformational, but it is not viewed with the same optimism the internet once had. The internet promised connection, access, and opportunity. AI promises efficiency, automation, and fewer workers in some functions.
That changes the psychology.
The stock market can still rally on AI earnings power, but the broader economy does not get the same feel-good boost if households believe the technology threatens their jobs. That makes the rally more fragile than a normal expansion-led bull market.
It also makes valuation discipline more important.
When the S&P 500 is trading at a CAPE above 40, investors need real earnings delivery. Not vibes. Not demos. Not “AI strategy” slides. Real revenue, real margins, real cash flow.
Space Investing (Sponsored)
Starlink — Elon Musk’s satellite internet project — is rumored to be preparing for a $100 billion IPO.
To put that in perspective: that’s 228X bigger than Amazon’s IPO.
Legendary investor James Altucher is showing everyday investors how to potentially profit before it goes public — for less than $100.
He’s even sharing a FREE ticker symbol for those ready to act.
The Rally Has Narrower Room For Error
The latest market action shows the strength and the risk.
The S&P 500 and Nasdaq hit fresh records, helped by tech momentum, strong earnings, and improving hopes around Iran talks. Micron surged sharply and became another symbol of the AI hardware trade. Futures were little changed afterward, which suggests investors are not rushing to abandon the rally.
But the setup is not clean.
The 10-year Treasury yield around 4.50%, higher inflation expectations, and a flatter curve do not support endless multiple expansion. At some point, expensive stocks need earnings to carry the next leg.
That is why broad index upside looks more limited from here.
This is not a market where you can blindly buy anything because the S&P is making new highs. The index can keep rising while more stocks become dangerous underneath the surface.
The best names are the ones with one of three traits:
AI exposure that turns into earnings.
Pricing power that protects margins.
Essential demand that holds up when consumers feel bad.
Everything else needs more scrutiny.
Bad Sentiment Does Not Automatically Mean Bad Spending
Here is the nuance: gloomy consumers do not always stop spending immediately.
People can feel terrible and still buy groceries, pay insurance, use software, travel selectively, and keep their subscriptions. A record-low sentiment reading is a warning, not a guaranteed collapse.
But the mix of spending changes.
Consumers become more price-sensitive. They trade down. They delay big-ticket purchases. They favor value. They cut back on the categories that feel optional.
That matters for stock selection.
A luxury brand, high-end discretionary retailer, or expensive consumer service needs a very different setup than a warehouse club, discount retailer, insurer, or software platform selling productivity.
The market can handle weak sentiment if corporate earnings keep beating. But if weak sentiment turns into weaker spending, the expensive parts of the market will have no cushion.
That is why investors should stay invested, but get more selective.
Actionable Stuff
Do Not Chase The Index Blindly
The S&P 500 at a CAPE above 40 leaves little room for disappointment. Buy quality, not momentum for its own sake.
Separate AI Winners From AI Narrators
The best AI stocks are turning the theme into revenue, margins, and cash flow. The weak ones are selling a story.
Respect Consumer Gloom
Record-low sentiment is not noise. It tells you households are under pressure from prices, gas, job anxiety, and war risk.
Favor Margin Expansion
Companies that use AI to lift productivity without damaging the customer experience deserve a premium.
Own Essentials And Infrastructure
When consumers feel bad and markets stay volatile, essential spending and market infrastructure become more attractive.
Top Picks
Microsoft (NASDAQ: MSFT) Microsoft remains one of the strongest ways to own the positive side of the AI divide. The company is not just talking about AI. It is embedding it into the enterprise software stack through Azure, Copilot, Office, GitHub, security, and workflow tools. That matters because businesses under pressure to do more with fewer people need exactly what Microsoft sells. |
Nasdaq (NASDAQ: NDAQ) Nasdaq fits this environment because market uncertainty is not going away. |
Costco Wholesale (NASDAQ: COST) Costco is one of the best consumer stocks for a bad-mood economy. |
Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE: BRK.B) Berkshire is the grown-up pick for a market acting like 1999. |
Bottom Line
The Big Takeaway
Stocks are pricing optimism. Consumers are pricing pressure.
What It Means
This disconnect can last if AI profits keep rising and earnings stay strong. But with valuations near dot-com extremes and sentiment at record lows, the market has less room for sloppy stock picking.
How To Play It
Stay invested, but get stricter. Own real AI monetization, market infrastructure, essential consumer value, and balance-sheet strength. Avoid fragile stocks that need happy consumers, falling rates, or endless multiple expansion. The market can keep partying, but you do not need to buy every name on the dance floor.
That’s it for today’s edition—thanks for reading! Reply to this email with any feedback or let me know which macro trends or markets you’d like me to cover next.
Best Regards,
—Noah Zelvis
Macro Notes